1991 No. 1, Previously Recorded By Joe Cocker And Others, Topped The Charts 35 Years Ago Today

Add Grunge on Google:
Google Discover

The No. 1 song on November 18, 1991, was a new version of a familiar classic that had also topped the charts 25 years previously — Michael Bolton's take on "When a Man Loves a Woman." Far from the first singer to cover the raw, emotionally complex love song that originator Percy Sledge took to No. 1 in 1966, Bolton's attempt followed recordings by the Spencer Davis Group, Johnny Rivers, Lou Rawls, Natalie Cole, Joe Cocker, and many others. Bolton's reinvention of the song as a slick adult contemporary love song for a mellow '90s audience was by far the most successful.

Bolton, something of a cornball crooner who was once a surprisingly solid hard rock singer, adores classic '60s R&B, and he got in a habit of including an overproduced and vocally bombastic remake of a song from that era on his studio albums. On 1987's "The Hunger," it was Otis Redding's "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay," for 1989's "Soul Provider," he covered Ray Charles' "Georgia on My Mind," and on 1991's "Time, Love & Tenderness," Bolton took on "When a Man Loves a Woman." That one would sit atop the pop chart for a single week.

Michael Bolton's When a Man Loves a Woman almost didn't get released

Many influential record industry people thought that Michael Bolton, who once nearly joined Black Sabbath, should apply his uniquely pained, sheen-coated soft rock style to "When a Man Loves a Woman." While in production on the "Time, Love & Tenderness" album, Bolton welcomed his Columbia Records bosses Donnie Ienner and Tommy Mottola into the studio. When he floated the idea of re-doing an old chestnut, the executives told him to go for "When a Man Loves a Woman," which was what Bolton was going to pitch, and which producer and organ player Walter Afanasieff also had in mind.

The singer later remembered the cover's genesis a little differently, claiming that he'd already cut the track before Mottola asked him to record it. "When a Man Loves a Woman" also nearly got deleted before it was released, following the results of an in-house study by a Columbia Records employee. "She tore it apart, primarily based upon the fact that there was no reason for anyone to ever re-record this song," Bolton wrote in Time. He took the criticism to heart, believing that he simply hadn't done a good job, and he returned to the studio with Afanasieff and made eight more versions before deciding that the original take was the best one. It became a hit because the artist didn't back down, with Bolton demanding it stay on "Time, Love & Tenderness."

Recommended