1993 No. 1, Meat Loaf's Operatic Comeback Opus, Topped The Chart 33 Years Ago Today
On November 20, 1993, the No. 1 song in the U.S. wasn't some trendy grunge, dance pop, or gangsta rap track; it was a bombastic piece of arena rock that sounded like it came from an epic electric-guitar opera. That unlikely hit song was "I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)" by Meat Loaf, a '70s artist who had been completely forgotten about. The extremely powerful vocalist and all-around hard rock showman hadn't seen the inside of the Top 40 since September 1978, when "Paradise by the Dashboard Light," a single from his bestselling LP "Bat Out of Hell," hit No. 39. After the long-awaited 1981 single "I'm Gonna Love Her for Both of Us" became a notable flop for the classic rock artist, Meat Loaf disappeared from the musical mainstream and the charts.
Well over a decade later, Meat Loaf came roaring back, quite literally. The motorcycle sounds that kick off "I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)" are but one of the over-the-top embellishments that bolster the operatic, throwback-sounding song that repeated the grand promise-making of "Paradise by the Dashboard Light." That proved key to Meat Loaf's comeback vehicle: revisiting what had made his '70s music so special. His reward was a single that spent a whopping five weeks at No. 1.
I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That) was years in the making
When Meat Loaf (Marvin Lee Aday) had to re-create his demanding "Bat Out of Hell" vocal work in two years' worth of concerts as he toured to support the album, his voice was left so impaired that he wasn't physically capable of recording again right away. Jim Steinman, the stage and theatrical rock composer who'd written "Bat Out of Hell" and helped invent the power ballad, instead recorded "Bad for Good," an album of songs he'd prepared for Meat Loaf. The two musicians weren't in contact for the better part of four years, but they reconnected in 1984 and discussed a sequel to "Bat Out of Hell." It took Steinman and Meat Loaf a couple of years to get the deals, timing, and personnel in place, and then a few more years to make the new album.
Finally, in 1993, the elaborate and lush "Bat Out of Hell II: Back Into Hell" hit stores with the lead single "I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)." Partially a duet, the guest vocalist on the song was little-known British singer Lorraine Crosby. She was hired to sing a guide track to be replaced later by a star like Bonnie Tyler or Cher, but Steinman liked her performance too much to let it go. Crosby appears with the boisterous Meat Loaf on the various versions of "I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)": the 12-minute album version, the five-minute-plus radio cut, and the nearly eight-minute video version.