The Untold Truth Of Randy Newman

Randy Newman is a man of many talents and, frankly, there aren't too many musicians to which one can compare him. As The Atlantic points out, many simply know him as the "Toy Story" guy, but over his five decades in music, his accomplishments are widespread and astonishing. While his movie music may be what most are familiar with, it's his ability to write and perform songs unlike any other musician that has made him so well-respected and iconic (as well as landed his 1974 album "Good Old Boys" on Rolling Stone's list of the 500 greatest albums of all-time).

Perhaps most of all though, Newman has simply worked hard at making music. In 1979, his brother stated that Randy was just a lonely guy who worked hard on his songs but never seemed satisfied with himself (per The Ringer). Despite this, he's always at least liked his own voice, according to Mastertapes, which is as distinct as the music he makes. He told the podcast, "I'm very hard on myself, writing and dancing, whatever I do. But I always liked my voice. I always felt fairly comfortable with it."

In 2000, The Jewish Journal called Newman a "misunderstood genius." Now approaching 80 years old, Randy Newman is still making music, clearly still working hard, and still winning awards.

Randy Newman was surrounded by music from a young age, and by 7 years old he was already learning to play the piano (per TV Guide). As described in "Randy Newman's American Dreams," it was his father Irving — who had himself abandoned the pursuit of a career in music — who had encouraged Randy to play. In fact, Irving had felt he had disappointed his family by going into medicine instead of music, according to Vanity Fair.

As Randy grew older, his musical skills improved, but the young Newman also suffered from extremely low self-esteem — in part due to being cross-eyed, which he underwent many operations to try and correct — as well as shyness. He worked to overcome this by developing a persona as a class clown who would crack jokes, skip class, and drink with his friends, while also rejecting religion and embracing atheism (per "Randy Newman's American Dreams"). He also received good grades with minimal effort, as told by Allen Adashek, a childhood friend who spoke to People. 

By this time as a teenager, music became Newman's solace. He wasn't a natural and had to work hard at it, and soon, he began writing and playing his own songs. In 1962, he released his first single for Dot Records titled "Golden Gridiron Boy," a song from the perspective of a kid losing his girlfriend to the high school football star — although according to TV Guide, it did not sell many records. Still, Newman received his first ever mention in Billboard, the popular music magazine, while still just a teenager.

While "Golden Gridiron Boy" failed to capture the audience he may have hoped for, Randy Newman would go on to study musical composition at the University of California at Los Angeles (although he didn't graduate) and secure a gig writing songs primarily for other people over the next few years after (per Britannica).

Rolling Stone describes Newman as having taken "the long road" to success, first writing hits for others, such as Three Dog Night ("Mama Told Me (Not to Come)") and Dusty Springfield ("I Don't Want to Hear It Anymore"). He even wrote a song for Frank Sinatra, titled "Lonely at the Top," per "Randy Newman's American Dreams." The song lyrics were, in many ways, the antithesis of a typical Sinatra song, even subtly poking fun at the star's lifestyle and fame. At the meeting where Newman performed the song for Sinatra, Sinatra left it befuddled and without saying a single word. According to Newman, later in life, Barbara Streisand and Michael Jackson also rejected songs from him (per The A.V. Club). 

Then in 1968, Newman released his first full-length self-titled album. It wasn't a huge hit, but it did bring him recognition (with more established and well-known artists continuing to cover his songs). Billboard at the time called Newman "a bright new writing talent" with "topnotch original material." It was the start of a long, long recording career for Randy Newman.

As his songs are satirical and ironic in nature, a listener is supposed to find Randy Newman's songs funny. Rolling Stone has even called Newman a "comic genius." According to Newman himself in an interview with The A.V. Club, that is precisely the goal of his music: to make people laugh, and he compares what he does to Weird Al Yankovic. 

Perhaps unsurprisingly, Weird Al has also cited Newman as an influence of his, per The Washington Post. Discussing "Sail Away," for instance, Newman explained to Rolling Stone that he concocted a song in his imagination that was a sea shanty for a slave ship. It's shocking when you realize this (especially considering how catchy his tunes can be), certainly, but he also says that making a song simply state that slavery is bad wouldn't be as effective. 

In 1992, The Baltimore Sun described Newman's songs as "darkly funny," "downright disturbing," and "brilliantly sarcastic," adding that all of this seemed to hurt his commercial appeal, which did not seem to concern Newman in any way. In 2021, Far Out Magazine described "Short People" as "vicious" but noted that its "jolly bouncing melody" is what made listeners seem to misunderstand that it's a song about an absolute maniac. "Because it was a hit," Newman told Rolling Stone, "the song reached people who aren't looking for irony."

Of all Randy Newman's film scores, it's likely that his music from Pixar's "Toy Story" franchise is his most famous. Although he had plenty of experience composing by the 1990s, Newman was scared to make music for "Toy Story," because he had never done anything like it before. "It started a terror in my stomach," Newman told NPR in 2019. He had never composed music for either a children's film or an animated film, but Pixar really wanted him.

He agreed and had an orchestra of around 100 musicians to work with, according to The Hollywood Reporter. Clearly, it proved to be a fruitful partnership and even snagged Newman an Oscar nomination. He composed the music on the next three "Toy Story" movies as well, winning an Academy Award for "I Can't Let You Throw Yourself Away" from the fourth film, as reported by The Associated Press. 

Newman told NPR that the reach of "Toy Story" is incomparable and brought his music to hundreds of millions of people who otherwise wouldn't know his work. Nowadays, Newman says he's more than happy to be known as the "Toy Story" guy over the "Short People" guy (per the Australian Financial Review). At his concerts now, he sees far more children than ever before and keeps that in the back of his mind when performing, sometimes leaving some of his dark-themed songs out of the rotation if there are too many young people in the audience (per THR).

When asked if he had stopped counting how many awards he's been nominated for, Randy Newman told USA Today, "No, it's special every single time." While awards are not his goal, he appreciates the recognition — which is good, because he's received a lot of it. Just two years after his first album, Newman's record label described him as "one of the world's great singer-writer-arranger-musicians" (via Billboard).

According to RandyNewman.com, since then, he has won two Oscars, seven Grammys, and three Emmys. He was inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame in 2002, where they described him as "one of the most musically adept and stylistically diverse singer/songwriters in the industry." He received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame in 2010. He was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2013, referring to him as "one of pop music's secret hidden weapons." 

Even approaching his eighth decade, Newman doesn't show any sign of slowing down, so there may be more awards and recognition yet to come.

Proving he's as human as the rest of us, during the boredom of the COVID-19 lockdowns, Randy Newman wrote and performed a song about quarantine. The song, titled "Stay Away," was first recorded by his wife and uploaded to his YouTube channel; he used it to raise money for the Ellis Marsalis Center for Music, an organization that assists young musicians in New Orleans.

In the video, Neman tells his viewers before singing, to stay 6 feet away from people, to wash their hands religiously, and to not touch their face. He would go on to perform the song remotely for "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert," where he joked that people were calling it the greatest song ever written (via Pitchfork). He also performed it remotely for a segment on "CBS Sunday Morning."

The boredom also led Neman to write a song about then-President Donald Trump, although he ended up never releasing it. As it turns out, Randy Newman isn't much of a fan. "I can't stand him, and I've never written something that was impelled by hate the way this one is," he told WBUR, explaining why he probably would never release the song. "Little did I know [Donald Trump] would make [George W. Bush] look like Winston Churchill," he also told Rolling Stone.