The Untold Truth Of The Amityville Horror

When most people remember The Amityville Horror, they imagine demonic creatures and angry flies. But before the alleged haunting began, something far worse occurred at 112 Ocean Avenue. A year before the infamous Lutz family moved in, the hell house belonged to Ronald DeFeo Sr., a car salesman with a bad temper, a big family, and a particularly scary son. Ronald DeFeo Jr., also known as Butch, was a troubled young man who often got into fistfights with his father. Butch was a heavy drinker, a heroin user, and a small-time crook. Crazier still, Butch once pointed a rifle at a friend, and he even tried shooting his own dad with a shotgun.

In short, Butch was bad news, and on November 14, 1974, the 23-year-old grabbed a .35-caliber Marlin rifle, left his bedroom, and proceeded to murder everyone in his family. He walked from room to room, shooting his dad, mom, two brothers, and two sisters as they slept.

After ditching the murder weapons and bloody clothes, Butch spent the next day hanging out with friends, before returning home to "discover" his family was dead. Acting distraught, he ran to a nearby bar where he asked the patrons for help. When the police arrived on the scene, Butch claimed a Mafia hit man had done the deed, but you can only lie about mass murder for so long before your story falls apart. The police quickly learned that Butch owned the same kind of gun used in the killings, and after they ripped his timeline to shreds, Ronald cracked under the pressure and confessed to the crimes.

Butch went on trial in October 1975, and while his lawyer tried to use an insanity defense, the jury just wasn't buying. By the time it was all over, Ronald DeFeo Jr. had earned six consecutive sentences of 25 years to life, and to this day, Butch is still sitting behind bars.

The horror started right away. As soon as the Lutz family moved inside 112 Ocean Avenue, green ooze started seeping from the walls, black stains appeared on their toilets, and flies appeared even though it was wintertime. On one occasion, George heard a marching band in the living room, but when he went to investigate, he found all the furniture shoved to one side of the room. As for Kathy, she reported invisible hands hitting and scratching her, and when she put a crucifix in the living room, the cross supposedly turned upside down and emitted a "sour" smell.

But while Kathy had it rough, it seems like George was losing his mind. He allegedly woke up every night at around 3 a.m., about the same time as the DeFeo murders. Soon, George had stopped taking care of himself, and he spent a lot of his free time chopping wood, which he used to keep a fire going in the living room in an attempt to ward off chills. The children also started acting strangely, and it's said they began sleeping on their stomachs — which is how the DeFeos were supposedly discovered by the police.

As time went on, the disturbances only escalated. Windows shattered, doors were torn from their hinges, and then there was the lion. George claims he tripped over a small lion sculpture in the living room, and when he looked at his foot, he found bite marks. Things got creepier still when George took the statue up to the second story, only to later find the lion had somehow made its way back downstairs.

And, of course, let's not forget Jodie, Missy Lutz's imaginary friend, famously depicted in the 1979 movie. According to Missy, Jodie was a demonic pig with glowing red eyes, and both George and Kathy reported seeing this spirit swine at different times. George even claimed to have found cloven prints in the snow. But the situation took a truly nightmarish turn when George saw Kathy both levitate off their bed and transform into an old woman. Finally, after 28 days of horror, something happened that forced the family to flee, leaving all their belongings behind. The hosts of Last Podcast on the Left theorize that George possibly attacked the family, prompting them all to escape from 112 Ocean Avenue and its evil influence behind forever.

Let's assume for a moment that the Lutzes were telling the truth, and their house really was haunted. So what was the cause? Well, some believe the demonic activity in Amityville was linked to one of the most stereotypical horror tropes of all time: the ancient Indian burial ground.

In The Amityville Horror, author Jay Anson (more on him later) claims the Lutzes were approached by a local historian who said their property had once been the site of a Native American mental asylum. According to the historian, the Shinnecock tribe had used the area as a sort of prison for their "sick, mad, and dying," leaving their unfortunates to die of exposure. The historian also allegedly said the Shinnecock thought the property was just crawling with demonic beings.

Then in 1977, a parapsychologist named Hans Holzer went to the Amityville site with a psychic who began channeling the spirit of an Indian chief. The chief offered up a slightly different story about the property's past, saying the area had once been an Indian burial ground. The spirit also "revealed" that the chief had possessed Ronald DeFeo Jr. and had chased the Lutz family out of their house.

While this certainly sounds creepy, there's zero proof to back it up. Firstly, the Shinnecock tribe never lived in the Amityville area. In fact, they lived 70 miles away. Secondly, members of the closely related Montaukett Nation have made it clear that the Shinnecock never left their sick to die in the elements. And most importantly, Chief Straight Arrow Cooper of the Montaukett explained to ABC that his tribe would never "go into somebody's body and capture their soul and control in a very negative way. ... That's not us."

So here's the truth about the Amityville Horror. It's a great story. It's also one of the greatest hoaxes of the 20th century, one that's been debunked multiple times over the years. As mentioned above, the Shinnecock Indian theory proposed by Jay Anson has totally been discredited. And then there's the issue of the cloven hoofprints. If you'll remember, George Lutz claimed he found demonic footprints in the snow, but according to investigators Rick Moran and Peter Jordan, weather records show there was no snowfall that particular day.

Even more damning, Anson's book says the Lutzes called the police several times, but the police didn't receive even one call from the Lutzes during their 28 days at 112 Ocean Avenue. What about all the windows getting smashed and doors that were torn from their hinges, you ask? Well, according to skeptic Joe Nickell, when he investigated the Amityville house, all the original fixtures were still in place, without any sign of damage.

Things really fall apart when you start talking about Father Ralph Pecoraro (Father Mancuso in the book), the priest who blessed the house. According to Rick Moran — who actually spoke to Pecoraro — the priest didn't encounter anything weird when he visited the Amityville home. There was no evil voice, no car trouble, no stigmata. In fact, according to Brian Dunning of Skeptoid, Father Pecoraro once gave an affidavit saying he never actually went to the Amityville home and only spoke to George Lutz over the phone. In other words, The Amityville Horror makes for an entertaining read, but the book is essentially a work of fiction.

At the end of the day, the only horrors that went down in Amityville occurred in 1974, when Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered his entire family. Of course, if you ask Butch, he'll tell you a totally different tale. After he was first arrested, DeFeo claimed voices drove him to kill, but over the years, he's changed his story several times. Most recently, DeFeo has insisted that he didn't act alone.

Butch claimed in 2000 that he teamed up with his 18-year-old sister Dawn to butcher his parents because Ronald DeFeo Sr. was so abusive. However, his sister didn't stop there and proceeded to murder the rest of the family. When Butch discovered what she'd done, he supposedly retaliated by shooting Dawn to death. Granted, it's a far-fetched theory, one probably meant to absolve Butch of slaughtering his kid siblings. However, there are quite a few people who wonder if Butch really did have help that night.

After all, it seems weird that DeFeo marched into several rooms, fired multiple bullets, and not one family member ever got out of bed. Was it possibly a coordinated attack with another gunman? That's what documentarian Ryan Katzenbach thinks, and in 2012, the filmmaker claimed he'd discovered an old handgun in the canal running behind the Amityville house. Katzenbach thinks this is proof of a second shooter, but the cops don't agree. Either way, there's no denying Ronald DeFeo Jr. had a hand in the murders, and whether he heard voices, had help, or was just stoned out of his mind, it's safe to say he deserves to be behind bars.