The 5 Best One-Hit Wonders Of Power Pop
Power pop started taking off in the '70s, with plenty of great examples from that decade — but over time, it's a genre that's become synonymous with one-hit wonder status. While plenty of bands deserve more attention than what they're given on the charts, we think we know why there are so many power pop one-hit wonders: because it's hard to say what power pop even is.
If you're a music geek, you probably have a vague idea of what power pop sounds like, but can you describe it? Pete Townshend coined the term to describe the music of The Who, but more commonly accepted answers veer a little left of center. Let this list of great power pop hits settle the debate. To represent the best of power pop's many one-hit wonders, we've selected five songs that have ridiculously catchy melodies, a helping of soaring vocal harmonies, and guitar hooks by musicians playing as if their lives depended on it. And, perhaps most importantly, these are far and away the most important songs by these artists to hit the Billboard Hot 100 — in some cases, the only ones to do so. Not to worry, though; many of these acts used their brushes with fame to build respectable bodies of work that include plenty of other songs to get stuck in your head.
Cruel to Be Kind — Nick Lowe
British-born songwriter-producer Nick Lowe may be far better known for his behind-the-scenes accomplishments than his own skills as a frontman; he produced the first five albums by Elvis Costello (an artist with plenty of great songs that nonetheless missed the top of the charts) and wrote Costello's beloved "(What's So Funny 'Bout) Peace, Love and Understanding." Most of Lowe's work as a performer with bands like Brinsley Schwarz and Rockpile are the very definition of cult favorites. But a song Lowe had in his back pocket since his time with Brinsley Schwarz, "Cruel to Be Kind," proved to be his most enduring work.
While its tumbling rhythm and sugar-sweet melody is textbook power pop, Lowe admitted that he had other influences in mind. "We do it now rather like it was when I first thought it up, which was a copy of 'The Love I Lost' by Harold Melvin [and] the Blue Notes," he told GQ in 2011. "In fact, it was on the radio the other day and I was quite amazed how differently I do it now." As Lowe's signature hit, "Cruel" just missed the Top 10 in America in 1979 and earned a new generation of fans after female-fronted band Letters to Cleo covered it for the teen comedy "10 Things I Hate About You."
Someday, Someway — Marshall Crenshaw
The incredibly catchy melodies John Lennon and Paul McCartney wrote for the Beatles — several of which caused unbelievable pop chart milestones — are considered a cornerstone of power pop. It's no surprise, then, that one of power pop's heroes started as a Beatle impersonator. Marshall Crenshaw toured in the national revue "Beatlemania" as Lennon before striking out on a career of his own, making a huge splash in 1982 with "Someday, Someway," his first (and only) Top 40 hit.
Taking inspiration from '60s rocker Gene Vincent, Crenshaw penned "Someday, Someway" in a New York City hotel room while on the "Beatlemania" tour; he later told American Songwriter that it was "the first one I wrote where I really thought 'Eureka.'" Crenshaw's role as a power pop icon extends beyond his one hit: He played Buddy Holly in the Ritchie Valens biopic "La Bamba" and co-wrote a power pop smash with the Gin Blossoms, the 1995 Top 10 hit "Til I Hear It From You." But he's never tired of "Someday, Someway."
"I still like it just fine, and I especially like the record we did," he told Songfacts. "The tempo and groove are just perfect, it doesn't sound dated and maybe never will, it's just good."
Sick of Myself — Matthew Sweet
Known for his intricate guitar work and eclectic influences, Matthew Sweet would be the last person to bother with a categorization like power pop. "Oh, I dunno," he responded in 1995 when the Los Angeles Times asked him to define his sound. "It must be some sort of song-oriented rock." But in the hazy landscape of the post-grunge explosion — an era that came to a shocking halt with the death of Nirvana frontman Kurt Cobain in 1994 — Sweet pushed forward with a series of albums that, while never enormous sellers, offered a bridge between classic power pop and the current trends of alternative rock.
Years after earning heavy rotation on MTV with the video for "Girlfriend" in 1991, Sweet scored his only Billboard hit single with "Sick of Myself," a rollicking number from the perspective of a lovelorn self-doubter who at least has the power to seriously shred. Using those guitar skills as a Trojan horse for infectious pop served Sweet well until 2024, when a stroke sidelined his career. "I don't think there's always a place for that sort of music," he said of his preferred work to the Los Angeles Times, "but I've been lucky by not fitting in, which has enabled me to fit in, if you know what I mean."
You Get What You Give — New Radicals
Perhaps no entrance and exit in power pop history was as dramatic as New Radicals. The almost anonymous group — fronted by singer-songwriter Gregg Alexander — took no prisoners with their 1998 debut single "You Get What You Give," a chugging anthem that was compared to Todd Rundgren and Prince while taking surprising potshots at other figures on the pop charts, literally threatening to beat up alternative and pop acts like Beck, Hanson, Courtney Love, and Marilyn Manson. Within a year of the track hitting the U.S. Top 40, Alexander announced the end of the group, making them a classic band that quit just as they were hitting it big.
But things worked out well for Alexander, despite admitting in a press release announcing the end of the group (as reported by NME) that he "was wearing a hat while performing so that people wouldn't see [his] lack of enthusiasm." He turned to songwriting and producing, scoring hits like "The Game of Love" for Santana and Michelle Branch and co-writing the Oscar-nominated song "Lost Stars" from the film "Begin Again." And fans kept holding on to "You Get What You Give" as an anthem of perseverance — including Joe Biden, who used the song to cope with the death of his son from cancer. Alexander was so moved that he reunited the group for Biden's presidential inauguration in 2021 and later began work on a second New Radicals album.
Stacy's Mom — Fountains of Wayne
As power pop evolved in the '80s and '90s, some bands associated with the genre, like the Cars and Weezer, had more success than anyone could imagine. But in the 21st century, no power pop band made one hit last quite like Fountains of Wayne. Named for a kitschy shop in New Jersey, the group, anchored by songwriter-bassist Adam Schlesinger and singer-songwriter-guitarist Chris Collingwood, released two albums in the '90s. (Schlesinger also scored an Oscar nomination in 1997 for co-writing a tune for a fictional band that became a real-life hit, the title song to the 1996 Tom Hanks film "That Thing You Do!")
Sonically inspired by the Cars and featuring a video that paid homage to the '80s comedy "Fast Times at Ridgemont High," "Stacy's Mom" was a silly but catchy song about a boyhood crush on a girl's mother. It proved irresistible to radio, becoming the group's first and only Top 40 hit in 2003. Despite its popularity, Collingwood later aired his frustrations with the song and its contribution to the band's eventual demise. "I tried to talk [Schlesinger] out of 'Stacy's Mom,'" the singer told Rolling Stone after his bandmate died of COVID-19 in 2020. "He was too good a writer to have that be his calling card, and the success of a novelty song means that's just what you are to the public, from that moment on forever."